Music Monday - Encouraging good practice habits in young singers

Most of my practice these days is incidental. I warm up my singing voice in the car on my way to school or waapa, then sing as required during lessons to demonstrate aspects of vocal technique. On piano, I accompany at least one song per lesson so most of the student repertoire is under my fingers when needed.

However, in these past few weeks I have had to play some new repertoire for exam recitals and audition self-tapes. This has necessitated some more formal practice sessions. One song accompaniment required quite a bit of work to master some tricky rhythmic passages. As always, I recalled the words of past piano teachers – my maternal grandmother and, later, Stephen Dornan. They emphasised the critical importance of regular (little and often) repetition of problem passages. Over a week I did some daily (tedious) slow practice on the accompaniment and was rewarded with the buzz that came when I could get through the whole song without mishap. The reward was quite tangible – without the practice sessions I couldn’t play the accompaniment without a sense of embarrassment. After 5 days I could – and then again, after a few days break from practising that song, the notes were still there under my fingers.

This set me thinking about the difference between motivating young instrumentalists versus young singers. With instrumentalists (young and old) no practice = an obvious inability to play the music and audible wrong notes. However, with young singers the songs are often musically simple. Singers with a good musical ear and quick memory, can sing a song with minimal practice. It might not be a convincing performance, text wise, nor use appropriate registration – but they will be able to find the notes.

So how do we motivate the young singer to practise? 

Classic FM published 10 tips to help you practice.

Most articles on practice emphasise the importance of goal-setting. For young singers, we can set specific and measurable goals around technique -eg sustaining a hiss or hum for a specific number of seconds / being able to produce a light, clear tone / brassy, louder tone, etc.

Bur when it comes to solo song repertoire, we teachers must work a bit harder to set goals that are recognisable by the student. It could be something like aiming for a particular vocal quality at certain phrases or assigning specific acting thoughts (actions) to phrases. Even then, the achievement of those goals is easier to recognise in the reaction from audience than by the singer themselves. 

As young singers mature and tackle harder repertoire, the rewards from productive practice are much more obvious to them. But good practice habits are best started early in life.

What are your thoughts on this? We would love to hear of your success stories!

Music Monday - More about Practice

Last week’s post about music practice generated some interesting discussion. Thank you to those who contacted me with anecdotal stories about students young and older.

I’ve been thinking and reflecting further on this essential component of successful music performance.

Our daughter, Hannah had an outstanding piano teacher. Sue’s students were typical suburban kids, but consistently achieved above - average results in their AMEB piano exams. Her own daughters all went on to become professional string players. The family are clearly extremely talented in music, but I have often wondered if a significant part of their professional success was their mother’s guidance about practice routines from an early age.

I have been searching (without success) for one of Hannah’s old practice books, but my recollections of a typical page would read something like this:

D major scale. Practise hands separately 3 times then together, slowly, 3 times

Gavotte. New. Try page one slowly, separate hands. 3 times each practice.

Revise List A and D pieces once each practice.

List C. Check bars 43-49 (wrong today) and practice slowly 3 times each practice

And so on.

Very specific.

This week with my Year 8 boys’ singing group, I quizzed them about their practice since the last lesson. Interestingly - but unsurprisingly - the boy who scored highest in a technical work assessment had the most specific practice routine. Here is what he reported as being his practice routine:

“I sang each of our (5) scales 5 times to warm up.

Then I sang the vocalise, checking the breathing and the dynamics.

I practised the song, checking the rhythms at the bars you told us to.

I recorded myself singing to make sure that I wasn’t scooping or sliding.

Then I went through my parts in Matilda (their current school musical).”

Again, very specific and ordered.

We are living in an age where technology provides so many tools for practice – warm up apps, recording devices on our phones, backing tracks with or without voice / piano / orchestra. The list goes on.

But as music educators we still need to train effective practice habits.